[ilds] Seeking the Truth

Bruce Redwine bredwine1968 at earthlink.net
Sat Sep 25 12:30:30 PDT 2010


Truth for the historian and truth for the poet -- two "different animals?"  Maybe.  This is probable the crux of this discussion.  But I don't know what this distinction means -- indeed, if it is correct.  And this is not what I take LD to mean by his relativity statement, which seems to me anchored in everyday reality.  True, he or his persona makes this claim in a fictional context, but the reference is to the real world.  He calls the Quartet an "investigation," so what is he investigating?  His own imagination?  No.  He's making claims about the world we live in, and that's why I call the statement "truth is what most contradicts itself" a bit of seductive nonsense.


Sent from my iPhone

On Sep 25, 2010, at 10:41 AM, James Gifford <james.d.gifford at gmail.com> wrote:

> Hi Bruce,
> I'd point to Durrell's strong support for Israel up to the late 1960s 
> (perhaps parallel to Judt) as well as his ongoing interest in History. 
> While he likely held very different views on epistemology from Judt, I 
> don't think there would be a necessary antagonism between them.  I 
> suspect you're blurring together two different contexts and two 
> different uses of the term "truth."  For political intrigue and personal 
> relationships, and most especially for poetry and fiction, "truth" is a 
> very different animal than it is for a historian.
>   As for the "polemical intellectual," I think there's a good deal more to 
> this than we often acknowledge.  /The Revolt of Aphrodite/ or "No Clue 
> to Living" give us some differing views on the subject.  I've tried to 
> write about it in an article that's appearing in /jml/ this month:

More information about the ILDS mailing list