[ilds] Author v. Reader

Ilyas ilyas.khan at crosby.com
Mon May 5 13:25:05 PDT 2008


Alejandro,
I don't think this list is meant to act as the forum for an exclusive
clique. Like many such email lists there is a preponderance of posts from a
few people, many of them specialist academics who have the time and the
resources to put into LD (or whatever subject is being discussed). My own
problem with your last message was based on what I felt was an unfair attack
on someone who has proven, over many years, that he is absolutely not
elitist. Or any other "ist" (I refer to Godshalk).

Anyway, thank you for your reasoned and very calm reply, and I must
apologise for having taken umbrage. Maybe we can agree to step back and
continue to enjoy the cut and thrust of the usual topics. I hope you will
agree that the advantage that you and I (and others like us) can take from
membership of this email list is the incredible wealth of information and
lateral thought that it provokes !

Happy bank holiday from London,

Ilyas 


On 05/05/2008 05:36, "Alejandro Adams" <hungerist at hotmail.com> wrote:

> Ilyas,
> 
> I intended to express that I felt INSULTED on behalf of certain lovers of
> Durrell whom I have known and who would never subscribe to a list such as
> this one because they don't feel "qualified" to express themselves on the
> subject.  But to suggest that I'm SPEAKING on their behalf, or on yours?
> That would be rather presumptuous.
> 
> I often feel that Bruce is speaking on my behalf (unwittingly of course, as
> we haven't yet formed the Quaint Layman's Brigade), which is a placating
> sensation.  He is quicker and sharper and better-informed than I and manages
> to put his ideas into palatable form.  Thus, I hardly ever feel the urge to
> speak up.  But sometimes the pelting condescension thoroughly erodes my
> respect for decorum at all costs.  If this list is intended to function as
> an exclusive clique, why not screen credentials?
> 
> Clearly anyone on this list could wipe the floor with me, but it seems vital
> that we brook dissent, no matter how impuissant the voice or unplain the
> English.
> 
> Alejandro
> 
> 
> 
>> Message: 6
>> Date: Sun, 04 May 2008 15:04:05 +0100
>> From: Ilyas <ilyas.khan at crosby.com>
>> Subject: Re: [ilds] Author v. Reader
>> To: <ilds at lists.uvic.ca>
>> Message-ID: <C44380E5.1013%ilyas.khan at crosby.com>
>> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="US-ASCII"
>> 
>> Senor Adams
>> 
>> You may well have some interesting ideas, but you sure as hell can't
>> express
>> them in written form. What on earth are you talking about and what are you
>> trying to say ? Ever thought of plain English ? I think you dislike
>> something that may have been written by "Mr Godshalk", but more than that
>> remains a mystery.
>> 
>> I am a casual reader, and you certainly did not reply "on my behalf".
>> 
>> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> ILDS mailing list
> ILDS at lists.uvic.ca
> https://lists.uvic.ca/mailman/listinfo/ilds




More information about the ILDS mailing list